Bonita Springs has quietly become one of Southwest Florida's most exciting dining destinations. Nestled between Naples and Fort Myers, this charming community offers everything from award-winning fine dining to casual waterfront seafood shacks. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion at Angelina's or enjoying sunset cocktails at Coconut Jack's, these ten restaurants represent the best of Bonita Springs dining in 2026.
Quick Navigation: Fine Dining | Waterfront | Italian | Seafood | Steakhouse
1. Angelina's Ristorante
Angelina's 30-foot wine tower holds over 4,000 bottles
Since 2008, Angelina's Ristorante has set the standard for fine Italian dining in Southwest Florida. This award-winning establishment combines authentic Italian cuisine with an impressive 4,000-bottle wine collection displayed in a dramatic 30-foot tower. The Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence winner (since 2012) and Golden Spoon recipient delivers an unforgettable experience.
House-made pastas, prime meats, and fresh seafood are crafted with ingredients imported directly from Italy. The elegant ambiance features romantic lighting and soft piano music, making it perfect for special occasions.
- Address: 24041 S Tamiami Trail, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 390-3187
- Cuisine: Fine Italian
- Price range: $$$$ (Entrees $35-$65)
- Best for: Special occasions, wine lovers, romantic dinners
- Don't miss: Veal agnolotti, mushroom risotto, pork osso buco
- Dress code: Business casual (no shorts, t-shirts, or beachwear)
- Hours: Mon-Thu & Sun 4-9pm, Fri-Sat 4-10pm
- Website: angelinasofbonitasprings.com
2. Coconut Jack's Waterfront Grille
Voted Bonita's Best Waterfront Restaurant from 2011-2023, Coconut Jack's delivers the quintessential Florida dining experience. Located right on the water with stunning sunset views, this casual spot serves up fresh Gulf seafood, Caribbean-inspired dishes, and tropical cocktails in a laid-back tiki atmosphere.
The menu features local favorites like grouper, coconut shrimp, and crab cakes alongside steaks, ribs, and pulled pork. Happy hour runs daily from 3-6pm, and complimentary valet parking makes arriving a breeze.
- Address: 5370 Bonita Beach Rd, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 676-7777
- Cuisine: Seafood, American, Caribbean
- Price range: $$-$$$ (Entrees $18-$35)
- Best for: Sunset dining, waterfront views, casual seafood
- Don't miss: Fresh grouper, coconut shrimp, rum runners
- Features: Tiki bar, outdoor seating, kids menu, gluten-free options
- Hours: Daily 11am-10pm
- Website: coconutjacks.com
3. The Bohemian Restaurant
The Bohemian brings chef-driven creativity to downtown Bonita
A relative newcomer that's quickly become a local favorite, The Bohemian offers chef-driven cuisine with global influences in an intimate downtown setting. Owners Brandon and Caitlin Schewe (who also own nearby Downtown Coffee Co.) have created an upscale yet approachable space featuring a rotating menu that changes almost weekly.
The Florida hardwood oak grill produces incredible dishes using locally sourced ingredients from neighboring farms and fishermen. Shareable plates encourage exploration, and the wine list perfectly complements the creative cuisine.
- Address: 27975 Old 41 Rd, Suite 104, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
- Phone: (239) 451-9619
- Cuisine: New American, Global
- Price range: $$$-$$$$ (Plates $16-$45)
- Best for: Foodies, date nights, shareable plates
- Don't miss: Cold-water oysters, tiger's milk ceviche, lobster buns
- Features: Rotating menu, local ingredients, intimate setting
- Hours: Daily 5-10pm
- Website: thebohemianbonita.com
4. Olde Florida Chop House
This intimate waterfront steakhouse at the Trianon Bonita Bay Hotel specializes in Florida-style dishes with a focus on prime cuts and fresh local seafood. The elegant lakeside setting offers both indoor dining with lake views and a beautiful outdoor patio.
Florida-raised prime beef, Wagyu steaks, and daily fresh catches like grouper and mahi-mahi headline the menu. The impressive wine list, craft cocktails, and attentive service make this ideal for business dinners and celebrations.
- Address: 3401 Bay Commons Dr, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 948-4400
- Cuisine: Steakhouse, Seafood
- Price range: $$$$ (Steaks $45-$85)
- Best for: Business dinners, steak lovers, lakeside dining
- Don't miss: Wagyu meatloaf, filet mignon, Kurobuta pork chop
- Features: Lake views, patio dining, private rooms available
- Website: oldefloridachophouse.com
5. The Fish House
For over 25 years, The Fish House has been serving the freshest seafood in a fun, casual atmosphere. Located on the water with boat docks for those arriving by sea, this laid-back spot is a favorite among beachgoers, boaters, and families.
The outdoor patio offers the best sunset views in town, and the dog-friendly policy means your four-legged friend can join you. Don't miss the famous 2-for-1 Rum Runners available all day, every day.
- Address: 4685 Bonita Beach Rd, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 495-5770
- Cuisine: Seafood, American
- Price range: $$ (Entrees $15-$28)
- Best for: Casual waterfront dining, families, boaters
- Don't miss: Grouper tacos, smoked fish dip, key lime pie
- Features: Boat docks, dog-friendly patio, sunset views
- Hours: Daily 11am-9pm
- Website: thefishhouserestaurants.com
6. DeRomo's Gourmet Market & Restaurant
DeRomo's combines an Italian market with a 275-seat restaurant
A unique concept combining a gourmet Italian market with a 275-seat restaurant, DeRomo's at the Promenade at Bonita Bay delivers authentic Italian cuisine using ingredients straight from their own market. The open-style kitchen and elegant café atmosphere create a luxurious yet welcoming experience.
From fresh-cut meats and imported cheeses to house-made pastas and wood-fired dishes, every plate reflects genuine Italian tradition. Grab a bottle from the market on your way out.
- Address: 26811 S Bay Dr, Suite 140, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 325-3583
- Cuisine: Italian
- Price range: $$-$$$ (Entrees $18-$38)
- Best for: Italian cuisine, market shopping, groups
- Don't miss: Fresh pasta alla vodka, lasagna, meatballs with ricotta
- Features: Gourmet market, outdoor dining, wine selection
- Hours: Lunch 11am-3pm, Dinner 4-9pm daily
- Website: deromos.com
7. Petar's Restaurant
Chef-owner Petar Alujevic has created a hidden gem that consistently ranks among Bonita Springs' best. This elevated New American restaurant showcases seasonal ingredients with artistic plating and bold, balanced flavors that have earned it a 4.9-star rating on OpenTable.
The ever-changing menu reflects Petar's passion for quality and creativity, from expertly prepared seafood to tender steaks and inventive appetizers. The intimate setting makes it perfect for special dinners.
- Address: 3300 Bonita Beach Rd, Unit 120, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 249-4064
- Cuisine: New American, Seafood
- Price range: $$$-$$$$ (Entrees $28-$55)
- Best for: Special occasions, foodies, intimate dining
- Don't miss: Salmon over risotto, blue crab salad, chef's specials
- Reservations: Highly recommended
- Website: petarsrestaurant.com
8. Roy's Restaurant
Bringing the flavors of Hawaii to Southwest Florida, Roy's offers Hawaiian fusion cuisine that's creative, bold, and utterly delicious. The signature dishes combine Asian spices with traditional techniques, resulting in unique flavor profiles you won't find anywhere else in Bonita.
The upscale setting, exceptional service, and inventive cocktails make Roy's ideal for celebrations or simply treating yourself to something different.
- Address: 26831 South Bay Dr, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 498-7697
- Cuisine: Hawaiian Fusion, Seafood
- Price range: $$$-$$$$ (Entrees $30-$55)
- Best for: Hawaiian cuisine, special occasions, unique flavors
- Don't miss: Misoyaki butterfish, macadamia nut crusted mahi, chocolate soufflé
- Reservations: Recommended
- Website: roysrestaurant.com
9. The Other Side Bistro
This charming bistro serves American cuisine with a French hand, featuring fresh seafood and homemade desserts from a scratch kitchen. The globally inspired New American menu, red-walled dining room decorated with art, and quality wine list have earned it a loyal following.
The lunch menu shines with creative sandwiches and salads, while dinner brings more substantial fare. Save room for the legendary bread pudding or crème brûlée.
- Address: 24630 S Tamiami Trail, Bonita Springs, FL 34134
- Phone: (239) 992-7433
- Cuisine: New American, French-influenced
- Price range: $$-$$$ (Entrees $16-$32)
- Best for: Lunch, casual dinner, dessert lovers
- Don't miss: Short rib grilled cheese, French onion soup, bread pudding
- Features: Dog-friendly patio, gluten-free options
- Hours: Mon-Fri 11am-2:30pm & 4-8pm, Sat 4-8pm (closed Sun)
- Website: othersidebistro.com
10. Carrabba's Italian Grill
For reliable, family-friendly Italian, Carrabba's delivers homemade Italian done right. Wood-fire grilled entrées, sautéed-to-order pastas, and their iconic Chicken Bryan have made this a go-to for casual Italian dining in Bonita Springs.
Happy hour brings great deals on appetizers and drinks, and the Carside Carryout makes takeout convenient. It's not fine dining, but it's consistently good comfort food.
- Address: 27220 Bay Landing Dr, Bonita Springs, FL 34135
- Phone: (239) 949-0981
- Cuisine: Italian
- Price range: $$ (Entrees $15-$30)
- Best for: Families, casual Italian, takeout
- Don't miss: Chicken Bryan, wood-grilled steaks, zucchini fritti
- Features: Happy hour, carside carryout, family-friendly
- Hours: Mon-Thu 11am-10pm, Fri-Sat 11am-11pm, Sun 11am-9pm
- Website: carrabbas.com
Tips for Dining in Bonita Springs
Best Areas for Dining
- Old 41 Road: Historic downtown with The Bohemian, coffee shops, and local charm
- Bonita Beach Road: Waterfront spots like Coconut Jack's and The Fish House
- Promenade at Bonita Bay: Upscale shopping and dining including DeRomo's
- US-41 Corridor: Chain restaurants and hidden gems like Angelina's
Seasonal Considerations
- Season (December-April): Reservations essential at popular spots
- Summer: Many restaurants offer specials and prix-fixe menus
- Stone crab season: October 15 - May 15 (don't order off-season!)
Parking Tips
Most restaurants offer free parking. Coconut Jack's provides complimentary valet.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best waterfront restaurant in Bonita Springs?
Coconut Jack's Waterfront Grille has been voted Bonita's best waterfront restaurant for over a decade, offering stunning sunset views, fresh seafood, and a fun tiki atmosphere. The Fish House is a more casual alternative with boat docks and dog-friendly seating.
Where should I go for a special occasion in Bonita Springs?
Angelina's Ristorante offers the most refined fine dining experience with its award-winning wine program and elegant atmosphere. Petar's Restaurant provides an intimate setting with creative cuisine, while Olde Florida Chop House delivers lakeside elegance.
What are the best Italian restaurants in Bonita Springs?
Angelina's Ristorante leads for fine Italian dining with imported ingredients and an extensive wine list. DeRomo's offers authentic Italian with the bonus of an attached gourmet market. Carrabba's provides reliable family-friendly Italian at moderate prices.
Do I need reservations in Bonita Springs?
During season (December-April), reservations are strongly recommended for Angelina's, Petar's, Roy's, and Olde Florida Chop House. Casual spots like Coconut Jack's and The Fish House are first-come, first-served but expect waits during peak times.
What's the best restaurant for families in Bonita Springs?
Coconut Jack's offers a kids menu and casual atmosphere that families love. Carrabba's is another family-friendly option with familiar Italian favorites. The Fish House welcomes families and even allows dogs on the patio.
More Bonita Springs & SWFL Guides
Ready to explore more? Check out these related guides:
- Retiring to Southwest Florida: Complete 2026 Guide — Planning your move to paradise
- 10 Best Waterfront Restaurants in SWFL — More stunning Gulf views
- Best Restaurants in Naples — Fine dining 15 minutes south
- Best Restaurants in Fort Myers — More options 20 minutes north
- Best Restaurants in Estero — Dining in nearby Estero
Have a favorite Bonita Springs restaurant we missed? Let us know and we'll check it out!
