Top 10 Best Restaurants In Fort Myers
Looking for a great meal in Fort Myers, Florida? Look no further than these top 10 restaurants, which have been rated highly by diners from all over.
Welcome to Fort Myers, a charming locale situated along Florida's Southwest coastline. Renowned for its historic river district, beautiful nature reserves, and Edison and Ford Winter Estates, the city is also a burgeoning hub of culinary delights waiting to be discovered. Embark with us on a savory expedition through the Top 10 Best Restaurants in Fort Myers, where an eclectic variety of gastronomic ventures awaits. From the freshest seafood catches from the Gulf, zestful Mexican cuisine, to comforting American favorites, the culinary scene here is as diverse as it is delectable.
Each dining establishment on our list presents a unique allure and tantalizing menus guaranteed to satiate your foodie heart, ensuring an unforgettable gastronomic adventure at every stop. So, without further ado, let's unravel the culinary treasures that make Fort Myers a compelling destination for every palate.
Here are the restaurants, ranked in no particular order:
Downtown House of Pizza
Downtown House of Pizza is a cherished establishment nestled in the bustling heart of Downtown Fort Myers, where the art of authentic pizza making comes to life. Witness the spectacle as skilled pizza chefs masterfully toss dough in the open kitchen, crafting each pizza to perfection before your eyes.
Established in 2005, this pizzeria has become synonymous with classic New York Style pizza, offering a slice of the Big Apple in every bite. Beyond the classic pizza offerings, their menu extends to fresh salads, hot & cold subs, and heavenly desserts including the timeless cannoli. Their commitment to freshness is unparalleled, with pizza dough crafted from scratch daily, adorned with fresh vegetables, high-quality meats, and cheeses.
Every weekday presents a new specialty pizza of the day, inviting patrons to explore a different flavor profile with each visit. The quaint courtyard seating at the back allows for a serene dining experience under the gentle Florida sun, accompanied by the soothing tunes of music. Downtown House of Pizza is not just a restaurant, but a locale where tradition, community, and exquisite flavors unite.
Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza
Capone's Coal Fired Pizza, located in the heart of Fort Myers’ historic River District, is an ode to the roaring 20s and the legendary Al Capone. With a tagline, "Pizza so good it should be illegal," this pizzeria extends an invitation into a bygone era where the allure of the prohibition era comes alive.
The coal-fired pizza, cooked in 800-degree ovens, is the star of the show, delivering a unique flavor and a crisp crust that is simply irresistible. The freshness extends beyond the pizza to house-made pasta and prohibition-style cocktails, enriching the dining experience with a taste of the past. The ambiance is a journey back in time with 1920s-style decor, where every meal feels like a jovial gathering in the heart of the prohibition era.
Amidst the vintage aesthetics, the modernistic tradition of the River District shines through, especially if you choose to dine in the outdoor seating area, offering a blend of history with contemporary comfort. Capone’s doesn’t just offer a meal, but a cheerful rebellion against the ordinary, one exceptional pizza at a time.
GinZa Japanese Restaurant
Immerse yourself in a delightful culinary journey at GinZa Japanese Restaurant, where the vibrant tradition of Japanese cuisine comes to life in the heart of Fort Myers. Nestled at 4429 Cleveland Ave, this gem of a restaurant invites patrons to explore an extensive menu brimming with authentic sushi and hibachi delights. Open from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM on weekdays, extending to 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays, and welcoming guests until 9:00 PM on Sundays, GinZa is a haven for those seeking to relish in the flavorful world of Japanese cuisine any day of the week
The allure of GinZa lies not only in its exquisite sushi offerings but also in the theatrical allure of hibachi, where the sizzle and sear of fresh ingredients create a spectacle of flavors and aromas. Their endless sushi and hibachi menu for lunch, dinner, and happy hour promises a gastronomic adventure that keeps on giving, ensuring that patrons leave with both full bellies and wide smiles. From the popular Rainbow Roll to the enticing Bubba Gump Roll, each sushi creation is a testament to the meticulous art of sushi making, reflecting a blend of traditional techniques with a hint of modern creativity.
The ambiance is welcoming, with a casual yet elegant setting that complements the culinary experience. Whether you're seated at the sushi bar witnessing the skilled sushi chefs at work, or at a hibachi table enjoying the interactive cooking show, every visit to GinZa is an enjoyable escapade into the rich and diverse flavors of Japan. It's not just a meal; it's an engaging experience that entices the senses and celebrates the nuanced tradition of Japanese cuisine.
Farmer’s Market Restaurant
Delve into the heart of southern comfort at Farmer's Market Restaurant, Fort Myers' oldest operating eatery. Situated at 2736 Edison Ave, this charming establishment invites diners to a cozy, rustic setting reflecting the rich agricultural heritage of the region. Known for its warm hospitality and hearty, farm-fresh meals, the restaurant brings the essence of homely, southern cooking to the table.
Each dish, crafted with locally sourced ingredients, tells a story of tradition, from the savory fried chicken to the classic meatloaf and fresh vegetable sides. As you relish the comforting flavors amidst a backdrop of vintage decor, Farmer's Market Restaurant offers not just a meal, but a nostalgic journey through the timeless charm of southern hospitality.
Three Fishermen Seafood Restaurant
Welcome to a delightful enclave of seafood paradise at the Three Fishermen Seafood Restaurant, nestled in the serene waterfront location of North Fort Myers. With a picturesque backdrop of the riverfront, accessible through the breezeway behind the Best Western Hotel, this dining haven is an epitome of a fresh seafood adventure that waits to be embarked upon. The calm waters that surround you as you dine add a touch of nature's tranquility to your meal, enhancing the culinary experience manifold1.
The restaurant prides itself on serving seafood in its freshest form, with meals prepared to order just the way you like them, be it fried, broiled, blackened, scampi, grilled, or steamed. The essence of the sea is captured immaculately in every bite, whether it be the savory fish tacos, shrimp tacos, or the grouper sandwiches that many guests rave about. And for those with a sweet tooth, the tasty key lime pie, peanut butter pie, and fruitcake provide a sweet closure to a hearty meal.
Every visit to Three Fishermen is more than just a meal; it's a celebration of seafood in an ambiance that exudes a relaxed family atmosphere. The restaurant breathes life into its belief that every meal should be a fun adventure, as reflected in their varied seafood combinations, house specialties, and the everyday lunch and dinner specials. The adventure extends to the beverage menu, where the delicious wine, margaritas, or rum complement the seafood fare, inviting you to relax and enjoy the panoramic waterfront views as musicians play live music in the evening.
With a full liquor bar, reasonable prices, excellent service, and generous portions served, the Three Fishermen Seafood Restaurant is a place where the bounty of the sea meets the hospitality of the South, providing a delightful escape for seafood aficionados.
El Gaucho Inca Steakhouse
Venture into a world where the flavors of Peru, Argentina, and Italy converge at El Gaucho Inca Steakhouse. Nestled at 4383 Colonial Blvd in Fort Myers, this family-owned bistro entices with a blend of authentic cuisines that promise an explosion of flavors. From the savory Steakhouse Parrilladas, refreshing Ceviches, to a wide array of seafood and pasta offerings, every dish is a voyage to the rich culinary traditions of the countries it represents.
Committed to serving only the freshest and highest quality foods, El Gaucho Inca Steakhouse ensures each meal is prepared to your desired taste. The restaurant takes pride in its three-country cuisine style, embodying a fusion of flavors that captivates both the adventurous and the discerning palate. Whether it's the grilled squid, fish ceviche, or the array of pasta dishes, there's a little something to satisfy every culinary craving.
The casual dining ambiance, coupled with professional service with a personal touch, makes El Gaucho Inca a delightful choice for a myriad of occasions - be it rehearsal dinners, business meetings, or simply a memorable meal with loved ones. The culinary adventure extends beyond the plate, as patrons can also indulge in a selection of fine wines and spirits, adding a perfect finishing touch to a delectable dining experience.
Izzy’s Fish & Oyster
Dive into a New England seafood haven at Izzy's Fish & Oyster, located at 2282 First Street in the bustling heart of Fort Myers. This inviting seafood spot brings the authentic taste of New England's renowned seafood right to Florida's Gulf Coast. Renowned for its delectable offerings, Izzy's Fish & Oyster presents a menu brimming with fresh seafood favorites, including their famous clam chowder, oysters Rockefeller, grouper sandwiches, and a variety of seafood platters.
The journey at Izzy's goes beyond the enticing menu, offering an upbeat atmosphere where every meal feels like a coastal celebration. Their Happy Hour is a crowd-puller, featuring $5 cocktails and $1 oysters that guests can enjoy while soaking in the relaxed, friendly ambiance of the restaurant. The charm of Izzy's extends to its thoughtful decor, embodying a modern, nautical theme that perfectly complements the seafood-centric menu.
Besides its regular offerings, Izzy's Fish & Oyster is also a hub for various themed events and special occasions. From Oktoberfest specials to 4th of July parties, and from Thanksgiving specials to St. Patrick's Day celebrations, there's always something exciting happening at Izzy's. They even add a local touch by participating in community events like the Fort Myers Art Fest, making it a vibrant part of the local dining scene. Whether it's the fresh seafood, the lively events, or the welcoming atmosphere, Izzy's Fish & Oyster is a cherished locale where every visit is a delightful maritime adventure.
The Lodge
The Lodge, situated at 2278 First Street, is not just a restaurant but a lively venue where sports, brews, and barbecues come together to offer a unique dining experience in Fort Myers. The place boasts the biggest LED TV in South Florida for the big game, a 50' projection wall for scenic views or Sunday Football, alongside 28 draft beers on tap, with 12 on a self-tap wall. The heart of The Lodge lies in its slow-smoked BBQ, with offerings ranging from smoked brisket, pulled pork, St. Louis ribs, and much more, all accompanied by a choice of five different regional sauces.
The menu is a parade of delectable BBQ delights, featuring various combos and platters like the BBQ Ribs Combo, Smoked Brisket Combo, and the St Louis Ribs Platter. The culinary journey extends to BBQ Tacos, smoked chicken salads, Lodge Angus Cheeseburgers, and a range of homemade soups and salads. Their sides like apple coleslaw, baked beans, mac ‘n’ cheese, and a variety of BBQ sauces add a comforting touch to the hearty meals.
The ambiance is casual yet buzzing with energy, especially on game days, making it a popular spot for sports enthusiasts. The Lodge is also recognized for its innovative self-tap wall, where patrons can serve themselves from a selection of draft beers, adding a fun, interactive element to the dining experience. With its hearty BBQ offerings, a vast selection of brews, and a vibrant sports-centric atmosphere, The Lodge is more than just a meal out; it's a social event where good food, good drinks, and good company are the order of the day.
The Standard Restaurant Downtown
Welcome to The Standard Restaurant Downtown, where the comfort of home-cooked meals meets the vivacity of downtown Fort Myers. Situated at 1520 Broadway, this family-owned gem has been serving the community with legendary food, cocktails, and hospitality since 2015. The restaurant thrives on its principle of offering fresh, home-cooked style dishes from a "made from scratch" kitchen. Executive Chef Jeremy Kurtz leverages his years of experience to bring strong, contrasting flavors to every dish served up to guests.
The menu is an ode to American comfort food, featuring a plethora of heartwarming dishes. From warm crispy tortillas stuffed with eggs, sausage, poblano, and a cheese blend, to a standard breakfast burrito, the offerings are as comforting as they are delicious. And for those with a sweet tooth, the deserts, all made on premise, promise a sweet ending to a hearty meal.
The ambiance of The Standard Restaurant Downtown carries a casual yet energetic vibe, making it a wonderful choice for a relaxing meal or a lively gathering. Its location in the heart of Downtown Fort Myers adds to its charm, offering patrons a chance to soak in the city's vibrant atmosphere while enjoying a satisfying, home-cooked meal.
Fancy’s Southern Cafe
Step into a gourmet haven at Fancy's Southern Cafe, located at 8890 Salrose Ln #101 in Fort Myers, where the charm of the south comes alive. This family-friendly spot is known for its heartwarming southern comfort foods, all made from scratch, providing a nostalgic journey with every bite. The restaurant has garnered attention, being featured on the Food Network’s “Extra Mile” and recognized as one of the top dining spots in Fort Myers by both local and national food critics.
The menu at Fancy's is a tribute to the comforting flavors of the south. Renowned for their breakfast offerings, the restaurant has been applauded for dishes like Chicken and Waffles and Meatloaf Sandwich. The ambiance is further enriched with cool decorations like old books at the bar, making it a cozy, inviting space to dine in. The place is equally famous for its excellent service and inviting atmosphere, where every guest is treated like a part of Fancy’s family.
Beyond the culinary delights, Fancy's offers a relaxing environment with live music, providing a soothing backdrop to the delightful southern meals. Their full liquor bar invites guests to unwind and enjoy a drink, adding to the whole cozy and comfortable southern dining experience. Whether it's the comforting food, the friendly service, or the relaxing ambiance, Fancy's Southern Cafe is a destination that promises a homely and satisfying dining experience.
As we wrap up our culinary expedition through Fort Myers, it's clear that this vibrant city is a treasure trove of unique dining experiences waiting to be discovered. From the enticing seafood fares along the waterfront to the comforting southern meals that narrate tales of tradition, each restaurant on our list offers more than just a meal; it's a journey flavored with culture, creativity, and a touch of Floridian charm. Whether you're a local food enthusiast or a traveler with an adventurous palate, Fort Myers' dynamic culinary scene invites you to explore a world of taste that promises to leave a lasting impression. With a blend of timeless classics and modern culinary delights, the Top 10 Best Restaurants in Fort Myers stand as a testament to the city's burgeoning food scene, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers from all walks of life.
For real-time updates, follow us on Facebook to stay connected with the latest in food, travel, and the best of Southwest Florida. Join our community of fellow foodies and adventurers, and let's savor every moment and every bite together. Bon appétit and see you on our next adventure!
Not feeling anything on this list? Cape Coral is a very short drive away from Fort Myers. Check out our hand-picked Top 10 Restaurants there!
